Why We Need More Restaurant Critics Who Are Vegan

Vegan croissant and working at Knella bakery, Barcelona

Going through my drafts folder in my beginning of year blog clearout, I stumbled across an unpublished review of Ethos restaurant in London, or least what was ostensibly a review. What had started out as a review of a new vegetarian restaurant that opened last year became a tirade against the typical newspaper/magazine review of vegetarian and vegan restaurants after I found a review by a major magazine of Ethos (it seems to have been taken down now so I can’t link, but I think you’ll recognise the familiar review “format”).

It’s still just as valid today as a year ago and one thing is clear: we need more vegan restaurant reviewers!

The review of Ethos follows the time-honoured vegetarian restaurant review format of:
“I was forced by my evil editor to go review a vegetarian restaurant and I cried myself to sleep for days beforehand. Finally I gathered my strength (gained through the consumption of copious steaks and never, ever any vegetables) and set out, reminding myself I could treat myself to a McDonald’s burger afterwards*.  As I ventured into this vegetarian establishment I was shocked to find it was not completely full of pale, thin, sickly-looking types, although there were a few _____ [insert insulting comment about subculture of choice here].

Somehow, they managed to feed me food – real, actual food! I always thought vegetarians subsisted on air, but they served me real food. And you know what? The food wasn’t bad. But on my way home I still stopped to dine on the most disgusting knock-off chicken meal at Kentucky Fried Crap, because although one paragraph before this I sung the praises of this vegetarian restaurant, I’m still not convinced one can actually go more than an hour without meat, and I’m going to close the article by telling you so.”

*Even though I call myself a food critic, I would rather face the banality of a meal at McDonald’s than the terror of a meat free dinner that might include – gasp! – an ingredient I’m not familiar with.

 

I’m sick of reading reviews like this written by critics who clearly hate vegetarian and vegan food, and food critics who decide (or are forced to) go vegan for a week or month and complain bitterly the whole time, like Jay Rayner in “My Vegan Hell“.  Jay Rayner, in turn, wrote a condescending review of Saf, a vegan restaurant in London, which included inflammatory remarks such as “But hell, a little light slaughter does seem to make things taste better.”

Worse still, I came across “Our restaurant reviewer explains why he’s become a (part-time) vegetarian”, an article in the Independent by Amol Rajan, a food writer who’d decided to go vegetarian, but felt he had to eat meat once a week in order to continue reviewing restaurants for a major newspaper (to be fair, it sounds like there may have been a bit of gluttony coming into play in the decision). The article ends with the telling line “And whoever listened to a restaurant critic who didn’t eat meat?”

Seriously? Have we not reached a stage where we can have vegans reviewing vegan restaurants – or at least people who don’t hate vegans and vegan food? When I look up restaurants, I tend to read reviews on blogs, Happycow, Tripadvisor/Yelp/etc.  I often read restaurant reviews in major magazines and newspapers as well but they are often absolutely useless to me – I don’t want to read a hate-filled diatribe about how much the food critic hates vegan food, or even a fear-filled section about how they’re scared of vegan food. I want to read a review of the restaurant from the perspective of someone who’s actually there to enjoy it (without preconceived notions and fear), damnit! And I’d love to see some major publications featuring vegans’ takes on non-vegetarian restaurants too, and what vegan options they find there.

The Oregonian have taken the forward-looking stance of having on staff food critic and vegan Grant Butler (who went vegan while writing for the paper), who adds a unique spin to the paper by reviewing restaurants (both veg and non-veg) from a vegan perspective.

This has got to be the way forward. As more and more people ditch meat and dairy, who will be the voice of food critics in the future?  Since I went vegan in 2008, things have changed positively – and fast. People no longer sneer when I say I’m vegan (usually), waiters now normally know what I’m talking about when I request vegan food, and more and more restaurants are offering dedicated vegan options.  But the food writing industry is lagging behind.

When will it catch up?

 

6 thoughts on “Why We Need More Restaurant Critics Who Are Vegan

  1. Cadry

    Yes!! This is SUCH a big pet peeve of mine. I get so tired of reading reviews that follow the exact pattern that you lined out. I’d like to hear their thoughts about the restaurant’s offerings without the diatribe detailing their own small mindedness around veganism.

    Reply
    1. Caitlin Galer-Unti Post author

      Exactly! It’s so unnecessary and incredibly off-putting (and not to mention insulting at times). How can we believe anything they write about the restaurant if they start out an article with a diatribe against veganism?

      Reply
  2. Joey

    *Gets up from seat, cheers* Every time – every time! – someone reviews a veg*n restaurant, they have to mention its veg*n, rather than go through their standard approach of commenting on the decor, service, the food they liked and didn’t. Equally, they feel obliged to mention ‘cliches of veg*n food being boring/bland/whatever’, which I think is always the sign of someone who hasn’t been to many veg*n restaurants recently, otherwise they’d know that such a statement was clearly cobblers.

    Reply
    1. Caitlin Galer-Unti Post author

      I know, right?! It’s absolutely ridiculous, I honestly don’t know how to take someone seriously when they go on and on about how they don’t like veg*n food or play on stereotypes right at the beginning of the article.

      Reply
  3. Catherine

    Great points, well made. And another thing: we vegans are generally over-enthusiastic with our reviews of vegan food because we are so grateful that the option is being provided and we want to support vegan businesses.

    Reply
    1. Caitlin Galer-Unti Post author

      Thanks! Yes, that’s another point about vegan restaurant reviewing and I agree, Catherine. I went to a great talk at a vegan conference a few years ago but Grant Butler (the vegan food critic at the Oregonian) about how to review restaurants and the topic came up and was discussed amongst the audience. The general consensus was that we are scared of harming vegan businesses. But we also give veganism a bad reputation if we give such glowing reviews to sub-par restaurants. Then non-vegans will go there and think “hmm this food isn’t that great but the vegans seem to love it. Veganism must just mean bad food.”

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *